What Dads’ Army?

Of late, I have read a few comments (even from experienced and respected commentators) suggesting that the Indian Team for the World Cup is too old! The term “Dads’ Army” has been used to describe the team!

The current players (with their ages in brackets in years and days at the time of writing this piece) are:

Anil Kumble (36y, 126d)
Sourav Ganguly (34y, 227d)
Rahul Dravid (34y, 40d)
Sachin Tendulkar (33y, 302d)
Ajit Agarkar (29y, 78d)
Zaheer Khan (28y, 136d)
Virender Sehwag (28y 123d)
Harbhajan Singh (26y, 232d)
Mahendra Singh Dhoni (25y, 228d)
Yuvraj Singh (25y, 70d)
Sree Sreesanth (24y 14d)
Munaf Patel (23y, 223d)
Irfan Pathan (22y, 116d)
Dinesh Karthik (21y, 264d)
Robin Uthappa (21y, 101d)

Firstly, the average age of this team is 27.68 years. I know that “average age” is but one metric that one may use to term a team “old” or “young”. Yet, I don’t quite know where the Indian cricket media have come up with the “Dads’ Army” moniker for this team!

Even the respected Siddhartha Vaidyanathan from CricInfo appeared to fall for this unsubstantiated hype when he asked Greg Chappell in a recent CricInfo interview:

The average age of the squad is close to 30, there have been comments about this being a Dad’s army.

To which, Chappell replied:

It is what it is. I can’t change it. It’s what we’ve got. You can look at the positive side of it and say we’ve got more experience than anyone else. The downside is that we’ll give away a bit in the field but hopefully we can more than make up for that with the experience with the bat and ball.

Firstly, Vaidyanathan is wrong. The average age is not close to 30! It is what it is. It is 27.68!

Second, let us consider the average ages of some of the other teams in the World Cup!

  • Australia: 30.75 (now that is close to 30!)
  • South Africa: 30.02 (now that is close to 30!)
  • Sri Lanka: 29.25 (now that is close to 30!)
  • New Zealand: 28.71
  • Pakistan: 27.73
  • England: 27.69
  • India: 27.68
  • West Indies: 26.67

I may have got some of the calculations wrong. If there are errors, kindly point them out to me.

In other words, just considering the average age as a sole measure for the legitamacy of the term “Dads’ Army”, the Indian team has a low average age! Yes, I know that the average age, in itself, doesn’t count for much. But this is one measure to explode a myth that has been propogated by the “braying mediocrity of Indian cricket” — its media!

— Mohan

9 responses to “What Dads’ Army?

  1. We have a good balance
    of young pacers
    and not so young batsmen.
    And explosives
    like Dhoni, Yuvraj and Uthappa.
    The perfect combo.
    I don’t care what the media says.

  2. Great post Mohan. Let’s keep poking holes into the popular media’s misplaced perceptions and writings.

  3. Srikanth Mangalam

    I totally agree. One thing that media has got away with not just with respect to cricket but news coverage in general is making categorical statements lacking any substantiated evidence or analysis. The more we expose this, the better informed the public gets..

  4. Pingback: Indian Team Too Old? A response « NAyK Home

  5. I remember reading that interview with Greg Chappel. I think the context is that India has quite a few seniors ( which helps in our batting strength tremendously ) but suffers a bit on the edges on fielding. In close games, saving a run or two matters. That is what Chappel is referring to. But then that is what it is. GO INDIA!!

  6. The press in India has its own way and it looks like ‘sensation’ (ofcourse senesless as well) is what sells (if they bellieve calling our team Daddy army is sensationlism!!!!).
    They completely igonored few postive facts. We have a team which contains players with (a) equal to or more than 3 world cup experience (b) we have players with one world cup experience and (c) and we have players who would like to impress well in their first ever world cup. That, I believe is the right mix

    I believe, winning the world cup is all about, experience, gut, attitude and skill and all these come only with age.
    The Indian press has to stop ‘biting our own back”. They can do a lot better motivating “Team India”.

  7. Pingback: News in brief: Friday 9 March 2007 « i3j3Cricket :: A blog for fans of Indian cricket…

  8. Pingback: Glimpses of the future… « i3j3Cricket :: A blog for fans of Indian cricket…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s