Team India Selection: Who will play?

Now that Team India is in the final stages of preparation prior to flying off to the West Indies, it is that time for fans like us to speculate on team-sheets and talk about who will play in the big games.

Unless they sustain an injury or a terribly sudden and inexplicable loss of form, it is safe for us to assume that Sachin Tendulkar, Sourav Ganguly, Rahul Dravid, Yuvraj Singh, Mahendra Singh Dhoni, Ajit Agarkar and Zaheer Khan are dead-certainties in every game that India plays. This list of dead-certs consumes seven positions.

We have to play four more. Given the above list, ideally this would be 2 batsmen and 2 bowlers — with the added condition that at least one of the two batsmen should be able to bowl at least 5 overs and share the 5th bowlers’ quota alongwith Tendulkar, Ganguly and Yuvraj Singh. Ideally, both of the batsmen should be able to bowl at least 5 overs.

The two out-and-out bowler spots could be

    A: [Munaf Patel and Harbhajan Singh] or
    B: [Sree Sreesanth and Harbhajan Singh]
    C: [Anil Kumble and Harbhajan Singh]
    D: [Munaf Patel and Anil Kumble]
    E: [Sree Sreesanth and Anil Kumble]

My personal preference is for [A] above. Under this option, I’d suggest that the team opens the bowling with Zaheer Khan and Munaf Patel. I’d also bowl-out Munaf Patel on the trot and send him inside the pavillion with a feigned injury — Dinesh Karthik can then substitute in the field for Patel! 🙂

The two other spots could be (two bats or bats-who-can-bowl):

    1: [Virender Sehwag and Irfan Pathan] or
    2: [Virender Sehwag and Robin Uthappa]
    3: [Robin Uthappa and Irfan Pathan]
    4: [Dinesh Karthik and Virender Sehwag]
    5: [Dinesh Karthik and Irfan Pathan]
    6: [Dinesh Karthik and Robin Uthappa]

As I have said in a previous post on this blog, “I do not believe that the team should look to have Pathan bowl-out his 10 overs. He is not, in my view, a 10 over bowler in ODIs. He should be treated as a “bit bowler” in the same mould as a Jacques Kallis or a Michael Clarke or an Andrew Symonds or indeed, a Virender Sehwag. That may help clarify his role in the team a bit better. Of course, there will be days when he bowls magnificently to have figures of 10-2-35-3. But then, these should be bonuses rather than the norm.”

Of the 2 batsmen combinations, I think we can eliminate [6] above since it does not satisfy the additional bowling caveat. Of the remaining five combinations, my preference would be to go with [1] above for the warm-up games. In this situation, Sehwag would open the batting with Ganguly. In the event that Sehwag does not hit his straps in these warm-up games, we should go with option [2] or [3].

Clearly, at least in my mind, the unresolved spot-tussle is for India to select 2 from Pathan-Sehwag-Uthappa. My feeling is that in the two warm-up games, all three should play to settle the issue.

I have a feeling that Dinesh Karthik will be a “Water Carrier” in this World Cup unless one of the bats sustains an injury or a terrible loss of form.

So, the team sheet for the warm up games should read (Tendulkar rested):
Uthappa, Ganguly, Sehwag, Dravid, Yuvraj Singh, M.S.Dhoni, Irfan Pathan, Ajit Agarkar, Harbhajan Singh, Zaheer Khan, Munaf Patel.

And it is likely that the team-sheet for the first two games

    March 17, Bangladesh V India — Group B match, and
    March 19, Bermuda v India — Group B match

(both at Queen’s Park Oval, Trinidad) could read:

Sehwag, Ganguly, Pathan, Tendulkar, Dravid, Yuvraj Singh, M.S.Dhoni, Ajit Agarkar, Harbhajan Singh, Zaheer Khan, Munaf Patel.

And yes, in this team, I would go with Pathan at #3.

— Mohan

7 responses to “Team India Selection: Who will play?

  1. Oh Please, I do not want Dinesh Karthick to be the Water boy. I am counting on him to be the Indian Star of this World Cup. Here is a line up for most India Matches, me thinks.

    Ajit Agarkar
    Anil Kumble
    Zaheer Khan
    Munaf Patel – his fielding is horrible

    4 bowlers + Sehwag, reinspired Ganguly + Sachin + Yuvraj can bowl – 10 – 15 overs. I think.

    Pathan has to compete with Sreesanth and Munaf for the bowling.

  2. Pathan competing with Munaf and Sreesanth for a pure-bowlers’ spot is a no-contest in my view. Pathan, in my view is not a 10-over-bowler. In my view, Pathan is as good a bat (in ODIs) as Karthik with the advantage that we can get 5-6 overs from him.

    — Mohan

  3. I am not comfortable at putting Sehwag back at the opener’s slot atleast in the early part of campaign. As a result, I think we should consider playing Uthappa. He is fresh, no baggage, and worth taking a chance with particularly if we want to get a psychological head start. If we play Uthappa, we may rest Pathan initially and play Sehwag in the middle. I tend to agree that Karthik is the most obvious choice for “bottle opener” with Sreesanth taking on the “Water Carrier” role…

  4. Srikanth

    I think we should also introduce a “towel provider” role and give it to Kumble! So we have a good cast with Karthik as “bottle opener”, Sreesanth as “water carrier” and Kumble as “tower provider”! 🙂

    Mind you, either or all of towel, bottle or water may get a game or two. They are, indeed, adequate covers for the regular personnel.

    So, that leaves 12 players. In a sense, I agree with you on the opening issue. I am hoping that the 2 warm-up games will settle the issue.

    — Mohan

  5. Sorry guys, we certainly need a Pepsi bottle opener, towel guy, etc. since our senior citizens will be chasing the ball to to the boundary all the time :-)) Could not resist this.

    I understand when the ball is hit straight to Munaf all batsman go for 2 runs.

  6. gnbmdr – You are giving far too much credit to Munaf. Run for two? The batsmen usually stay their ground and let the ball run to the boundary 🙂

  7. My 70 paise worth on who should play –

    I think Uthappa should open with Ganguly and Sehwag should come in at No. 3. This would mean Pathan would have to sit out.

    At least this should be the team for the first two games..It will also give Sehwag a bit of confidence at the top order before he plays the bigger games. Is that a good enough reason for him to even open? Maybe, yes – in which case Uthappa comes in at No. 3.

    I feel that Uthappa should play – and should be first choice – ahead of the likes of Pathan & Karthik. With four full time bowlers, we do not need another allrounder – I am sure Sehwag, Ganguly, Yuvraj and Tendulkar can more than make up the remaining 10 overs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s