3rd ODI review and my team for 4th ODI


The review is a bit late in the coming and it is really not a review. It is more of whinge. The reason for being late has nothing to do with being dumbstruck by India’s performance, but the way India played I could be easily be excused for being just that 🙂

After watching the 3rd ODI, the only thing that struck me was that there was no way India was going to win this 7 match series. I know I may get flamed for saying this, but I repeat – India is not going to win this series.

So, what are my reasons for saying that?

  • We still depend on our batting to carry us through – particularly Tendulkar, Ganguly and Dravid. And if they fail, we need the younger generation to step up. This is just not happening.
  • Fielding is still pretty woeful. Dravid has a tough time hiding the Munafs and Sauravs in the field and even the others aren’t exactly setting the field on fire.
  • Apart from the slow bowlers – Powar and Chawla, and to a certain extent RP Singh, nobody has been impressive. Zaheer has been OK, but has not looked threatening. Agarkar and Munaf are proving more of a liability than anything else. I wouldn’t be surprised if India go back to their old formula of 2 fast bowlers (Zaheer and RP) and the 2 spinners, with part time bowlers filling in the 5th bowler slot for the 4th ODI.
  • As Mohan pointed out, India have had a long tour and have lost the intensity that they had in the test series. It is very hard to infuse a fresh bout of energy now.

India may still win a couple of games, but I don’t see them taking the series. I’ll happily eat my words if they do.

Now for the team. I have a feeling India will give Uthappa a game. Although I believe that Uthappa has to open the batting with Ganguly, the team management will not break the opening pair of Tendulkar and Ganguly. So, if Uthappa does play, he will come in at No. 3. This will be followed by Dravid, Yuvraj, Dhoni and Karthik. If the bowlers are picked on merit, Powar, Chawla, Singh and Khan will make up the bowling attack.

So here is my team:

Tendulkar, Ganguly, Uthappa, Dravid, Yuvraj, Dhoni, Karthik, Chawla, Powar, Singh, Khan

The only change to this would be Agarkar coming in for Uthappa if Dravid prefers a 5 man bowling attack.

Is this team capable of beating England? Probably not. But if we bat first and put up a big score, we stand some chance.

-Mahesh-

Advertisements

10 responses to “3rd ODI review and my team for 4th ODI

  1. It is so clear Munaf is a bad fielder. He is no McGrath as a bowler. He should be dropped for the next one-day.

    Monty Panesar worked on his fielding and he is decent now. Why is our Junta not even making an effort to become “decent” fielders.

    Ganguly is untouchable, so India has to bite the bullet for his fielding lapses. Siddharth Vaidhyanthan had a scathing article on CricInfo about Indian fielding and had mentioned about Ganguly and Karthik.

    “He’s supposed to be one of the better in-fielders but when the umpire calls ‘play’ he seems to think he’s part of a drama troupe. He’s a fine actor, sliding unnecessarily and acting as if he’s the most energetic man out there, but he can’t stop what he should and tries to cut off what he really can’t”

  2. Whatever happens to the match, it is time the great batting trio Sachin, Rahul and Sourav announce their retirement from ODIs. It is no more their cup of tea. Induction of youngsters is overdue.

  3. Actually, I want them to hang around till the Australian tour…then hang up their one day boots.

    (Mainly for my own selfish reasons 🙂 – Want to watch them live one last time ;))

  4. I meant retirement only from ODIs. The great trio, infact the quartet, should be playing the tests for some more time.

  5. Laxman was dropped from one-day team for his poor fielding.

    Why was Munaf Patel, a poor fielder, not a McGrath like bowler , and not fully fit, selected ?

    Vengayasarkar should be held responsible for such selections.

  6. Pingback: I told you so… « i3j3Cricket :: A blog for fans of Indian cricket…

  7. Pingback: A win at last! « i3j3Cricket :: A blog for fans of Indian cricket…

  8. Pingback: Some observations about the Eng vs Ind ODI series « i3j3Cricket :: A blog for fans of Indian cricket…

  9. Pingback: 3rd ODI India Vs England- Review (27 Aug,2007, Edgbaston) | IndiaKnows.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s