Dravid made the right decision

Mahesh has analysed the reasons for Rahul Dravid’s decision to quit as captain of Team India.

This issue has been thrashed to death in the media in India Once again several ex-players and expert-wannabes have been wheeled in and out of TV studios to talk the issue to death. A cricket-related exciting news item is probably the only thing that stirs up the emotions — as well as a parade of expert-wannabes — in the media in India. A heck of a lot of newsprint as well as bytes have been swallowed up by this news already. Ironically, most media outlets have been quite glib in reporting that the irrepressible media in India may have been one of the reasons for Dravid’s seemingly hasty decision — the media that cites this as a reason thereby, by merely reporting this as a factor, attempts to exclude itself from the “irrepressible media in India” collective! There has been very little analysis but a lot of scuttlebutt and rumour in the media in India. The more serious analysis has been on Cricinfo. In an well-written piece, Siddhartha Vaidhyanathan bemoans a legacy that lost its way. And Ian Chappell opines that

Dravid’s decision was right, in my view. I personally feel that the BCCI did not deserve a professional like Rahul Dravid, and in announcing his decision to quit, Dravid has severed his ties with an idiotic organisation that would not be able to organise a booze party in a brewery. The professional in Dravid had perhaps rubbed against the idiocy of the BCCI machinery once too often. He was perhaps tired of dealing with an organisation that did not have a strategic-vision or a success-blueprint. It continues to stumble from one thing to the next and finds itself with a half-baked alternative to the ICL, a team without a manager and now, a team without a captain.

Sourav Ganguly was perhaps able to deal with the extreme ambiguity that exists in BCCI-land. He, in fact, thrived on it and may have even, at times, used this as rope to do what he pleased! Rahul Dravid, the organisational-allegience-type-of-professional perhaps found it hard to cope with.

He quit when he was ahead. To quit after the World Cup would have been a bit too much for him and his pride as a leader. He now had reason to exit on a high and on his terms.

Some media-experts have labelled him as opportunistic and a few others claimed that he put his own self-interest ahead of those of the team. We can argue about the merits of these judgements till the cows come home. But the country and its media must pay a price for the tripe that gets put out. Sooner or later, someone has to pay the price for the constant random-speculations, the irrepressible-intrusiveness, the needless scuttlebutt and the opinion-dominated tripe. Moreover, the bottom line is that an organisation like BCCI that exists comfortably in a strategy-free zone gets what it deserves — and it certainly does not, in my view, deserve a strong, visionary, dedicated, skilful, composed, articulate, determined and courageous leader like Rahul Dravid.

Rahul Dravid had to fight for a bowling coach and a fielding coach. I do not believe he won the team-selection battles — he can’t have got the teams he wanted. The team still does not have a full-time media manager.

Something had to give… It did.

The time was right for him to leave on his termsa and leave the BCCI to pick up a few more pieces. They are, after all by now, so used to picking up pieces — those that create the mess need to clean it…

– Mohan

9 responses to “Dravid made the right decision

  1. The Indian Cricket Fan did not deserve a professional like Dravid. They are still drunk on Ganguly’s histrionics, and the Ganguly era looks rosier with each passing day.

    Credit to Dravid for following his instincts, much like Tendulkar did in 2000. Unlike both of them, Ganguly carried on for 12-15 months too many.

  2. All it takes for evil to prevail is for good men to do nothing and Dravid is one of the “few good men” in Indian cricket – he had the professionalism and maturity to take Indian cricket forward and IMHO, he should have stayed till someone was ready to take over from him. But, maybe (as you mentioned) it was the same maturity and professionalism that made it difficult to handle BCCI (=evil) and its machinations.

    It is easy to say that it is actually BCCI’s problem – which it is, which they created and for which they should be responsible for. And we all know how well they handle things. In the end it is only Indian cricket and its fans who suffer…

  3. The sun will still arise from the east horizon tomorrow morning!!!

  4. Its easy to blame BCCI for Dravid’s decision to quit. It the ultimate cop out…..

    Dravid’s decision had more to do with public reaction to the job than with BCCI…. i don’t see how any reasonable person can blame BCCI (even though i agree that this is the default answer programmed into everyone’s mind) for this…

  5. I am not blaming Dravid’s decision to quit on BCCI – but only blaming them for not grooming a successor in time…

    When we knew that five of the seniors (Dravid, Tendulkar, Ganguly, Laxman, Kumble) are due to retire in a year or two, BCCI should have picked a vice-captain who would last longer than them – why would you name Tendulkar as the vice-captain starting with the Bangladesh tour? That is my only whinge…

  6. Dravid will be known as one of the great batsmen india produced but not a great leader.
    His reason to quit captaincy was that he wanted to concentrate in his batting.

    I personally feel he wants to be a living legend like Sachin. Ofcourse the burden of captaincy did effect his batting and he averaged very low in south africa and england. If this have continued for over a yr or two, he might have lost his nickname “THE WALL”.
    In this modern world, if u want to be succesful, u have to think of yourself first.

  7. Also, his decision has come just a right time. 2 or 3 yrs from now, the great TRIO sachin,dravid n ganguly will retire. So BCCI should start grooming someone( may be dhoni or yuvraj) who will be representing India in near future.

  8. Who might you have picked in the last two years? Can you think of one single candidate?

    Sehwag was being groomed, but his batting fell away…. Kaif was being groomed, but the same thing happened to him.

    Now Dhoni is being groomed, but i’d say he’s a year away.

  9. @kartikeya
    u are abs right friend.
    but u got to move on does not matter how many failures come ur way.

    after so long once india found an excellent captain named ganguly. now ganguly’s era is over. it doesnt mean u stop ur quest for the right leader.
    sehwag and kaif failed due of their own reasons. BCCI supported both of them.
    now lets c can dhoni or yuvraj can follow ganguly’s way or dravid’s path.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s