India Team for 4th and 5th ODIs

The Indian selectors have announced the team for the 4th and 5th ODIs against Australia. It sees only one change to the team that played the first 3 ODIs. Murali Kartik, the left-arm spinner comes in for Romesh Powar.

This, in my view, is a future step into the past!

I accept an argument for a left-armer in the team. We probably need a spin bowler in the middle-overs that can take the ball away from the strong Australian right-handed middle order!

So what is Yuvraj Singh doing in the team then?

I accept that, at 30, Murali Kartik is perhaps a much more developed bowler now than he was a few years back. Why? He may even be the best left-arm-slow bowler in the land. For sometime now, Dilip Vengsarkar, the Chief Selector, has often bemoaned the state of left-arm slow bowling stocks in India. In the past, he and his team of selectors, which includes Venkatapathy Raju in its midst, have shown faith in Rajesh Pawar, the 28-year old Baroda/Mumbai bowler. Indeed, Pawar even went to Bangladesh earlier this year as part of the India team!

In the past few years, India has tried several left-arm-slow bowlers in a desperate bid to revive what has been a thriving art-form in India. In a land that has produced the likes of Bapu Nadkarni, Bishen Bedi, Dilip Doshi, Ravi Shastri, Maninder Singh and even Sunil Joshi and Venkatapathy Raju, the cupboard was thoroughly bare. The reason for Tendulkar’s difficulty with left-armers like Ashley Giles, Daniel Vettori, Paul Harris, Ray Price, et al, has been put down to the fact that India has lost its ability to groom left-arm-slow bowlers.

In the landmark 2001 series against Australia, India tried three left-arm trundlers in the three Tests — Rahul Sanghvi, Venkatapathy Raju and Nilesh Kulkarni (in that order, at Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai). It did not help that Sourav Ganguly had nothing but contempt for both left-arm-slow bowlers and Murali Kartik! Murali Kartik did play in Australia in 2003, but made a meal of his chances and was forgotten after that.

So, it doesn’t come as a surprise that the search for that elusive leftie continues. However, two questions arise. Why continue this search in a high-powered-ODI series, and that too when the team is 0-2 down to an all-powerful and all-conquering Australian lineup?

Murali Kartik was himself surprised by the call-up! Despite a few successful county stints with Lancashire and Middlesex (this year) — he has been so successful at Middlesex this year that they have, reportedly, already signed him up for next years’ season — he has not been a part of the frame for an India comeback! The selectors have been grooming Pragyan Ojha and Rajesh Pawar instead. Recent representative teams have included Ojha, the Hyderabad left-armer and/or Pawar, the Baroda player. Murali Kartik wasn’t included in recent India-A teams or the RoI team for the Irani Trophy!

Given that scenario, Kartik is currently working as a TV media analyst in the Australia-India series!

Don’t get me wrong. Murali Kartik is, in my view, a good left-arm spinner — perhaps the best in India. But let us remember that this is not a Test series! Do we really think Murali Kartik will get a game? In whose place? And what does his presence do to team-balance? His presence, in my view, upsets balance. Of course, unless he replaces one of the bowlers? Sure, that is possible. But who will he replace? Zaheer Khan? Harbhajan Singh? Sreesanth?

Team balance screams for India to groom allrounders. Blind Freddie will tell you that. Instead of looking to the future to groom “allrounders” like S. Badrinath, Manoj Tiwary — a player who has put his hand up to be considered as an allrounder in recent times — Joginder Sharma or Praveen Kumar, a re-look at a player like Murali Kartik in the ODI framework appears to me to be a throwback to a dull and listless past.

Sure spinners mature late and I have no problem with Kartik playing matches. But ODIs? Especially in an environment where the key area where Team India hurts most — and this should be obvious to anyone following Indian ODIs in recent months — is in the area of team-balance affected by the lack of allrounders.

Ho hum!

— Mohan

7 responses to “India Team for 4th and 5th ODIs

  1. Dear Sir,
    I love your site very much and want to put my link on your site, so if you have no problem then please visit my site and if you like my site then put my link on your.

  2. Murali Karthk had a superb season at Lancashire. He has been rewarded for that. Is that not fair – selection based on merits ?

    It is not possible throw some rookie spinner against Symonds and Hayden unless India has given up on this one-day series.

    There is a fundamental problem – dearth of spin talent in India and there are more pace bowling talent as compared to spinners.

    How come other countries are able to produce match winning spinners and India is not (other than Kumble).

    P. L. Harris, Panesar, Vettori, …

  3. Vengaya Sarkar is on the news giving ultimatum to Senior players. ” Youngsters won T20 and if Seniors do not perform, they will be dropped “.

    Obviously, it is a broadside intended for Dravid. Vengayam would not dare say anything about Sachin (also from Bombay). Dravid when he quit captaincy, did not inform Vengayam and I am sure he is still fuming from that.

  4. Vengsarkar is a fool giving these kind of statements in the media. Why can’t he convey his thoughts privately to the members for whom these statements are made?

  5. Selector is not the leader of a team.

    Dhoni as the captain should convey to specific players what he expects from each player – “Sachin I want a big innings from you today; Harbhajan, I need 3 wickets in the middle overs from you.”

    It is just that Vengasarkar thinks too much of himself.

  6. gnbmdr – now I know where u r from! ha

    I sometimes don’t understand what is this elusive future everyone wants our team to go towards. I mean, don’t we want to win games today and hopefully winning will become a habit and help us win the future no matter who the personnel is?

    Kartik may not have won the game today for us but he definitely made a big difference. Despite our pacemen dishing out more crap today, our spinners pulled it back for us.

  7. Offering deals on the landing page is a good way to
    attract visitors. They are neew and look cool and they cover a larger area of the
    eyes and the face. When you arre in thiss business, always choose and
    decide on what your main concentration will bee and how to adverise and reach out to your target market.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s