The above report lays stress on two important words – Speculation and Perception.
Dictionary.com throws up the first four results for ‘speculation’ as
|1.||the contemplation or consideration of some subject: to engage in speculation on humanity’s ultimate destiny.|
|2.||a single instance or process of consideration.|
|3.||a conclusion or opinion reached by such contemplation: These speculations are impossible to verify.|
|4.||conjectural consideration of a matter; conjecture or surmise: a report based on speculation rather than facts.|
The most interesting definition is no 4 where the example phrase used cleary says that there are no facts involved.
As for ‘perception’ here are the results from the same site
|1.||the act or faculty of apprehending by means of the senses or of the mind; cognition; understanding.|
|2.||immediate or intuitive recognition or appreciation, as of moral, psychological, or aesthetic qualities; insight; intuition; discernment: an artist of rare perception.|
|3.||the result or product of perceiving, as distinguished from the act of perceiving; percept.|
Here again the meaning shows it is not based on any factual data.
The reason why I am posting the relevant meanings here is that whatever Gilchrist said has no factual basis first, based on the language that he has used. Secondly it gives us free rein to indulge in some ‘speculation and perception’ of our own. So here is a list of interesting conclusions of coursed based on ‘speculation and perception’
1. Gilchrist was asked by his publishers to wait and see if Australia was doing well in the series before coming out with his views on some of the Indians.
2. Gilchrist did not want to write about Sachin but was forced by his publishers, else he would not be paid his full advance for the book.
3. Gilchrist’s book was completely ghost written and he had no say in the things that were written there.
4. Gilchrist had some personal financial troubles because of the global meltdown, and he thought of including some sensational stuff to get a fat advance and boost the sales through the publicity it got.
Now that we have set the tone we can come with some other such conclusions on certain other issues using the same ‘speculation and perception’ method.
1. Andrew Symonds was asked by Cricket Australia to go on a fishing trip, so that they could drop him and avoid any embarassment if there was a repeat of ‘monkeygate’ in India.
2. Cameron White was included ahead of a specialist spinner because, Ponting felt that IPL players will get some mileage and help their value when transfers came up later.
3. Peter Siddle was included in the Second Test because a Test appearance in India will help his chances for a future IPL contract.
4. Michael Clarke did not play the IPL because he was warned by Cricket Australia that he may not be considered for captaincy after Ponting.
5. Ponting and Lee had decided to ‘act’ out a spat in public to deflect the attention from an impending Mohali loss just a bit.
My creative juices are just drying up but others are welcome to chip in with more including ones about why I posted this!