The Indian fan can dream… again!

The Indian fan can dream. The Indian fan first started dreaming in 2001 after “that series”! Team India fans will not need to know either the opponent or the score or the city. The term “that series” is sufficient to know that what we are talking about is 2001, Kolkata, Laxman, Harbhajan, 281!

The dreams were premature then.

India was not able to reproduce that 281 intensity in a consistently strong manner. There were several ills in the system that needed fixing. They are not fixed yet! Although the leadership, through Sourav Ganguly, tried to instill a sense of passion and pride, the playing group could still not be accused of either having or yearning for a “winning mindset”.

Although the ills in the system are still not fixed — the BCCI is the only organisation that is capable of making both the Zimbabwean Board as well as the ICC look good — and although these ills still exist, the Indian fan can dream again because of her players and the attitude that they bring to the table these days.

The ills in the system commence from grass roots selection and weed all the way through to talent nurturing, jobs-for-the-boys, organisation and more. Much more.

However, what a cricket fan dreams about is playing well and winning. And winning in cricket is about having the right resources, the right support systems, the right leadership, the right systems, the right processes, the right media, the right talent and the right attitude — not necessarily in that order.

Digging into all of the above-mentioned pillars of success is an article or two at least and perhaps we should undertake a detailed inventory of where Indian cricket is exactly at. But not right now! But briefly, one could argue that the resources in India have improved. We have several Cricket Academies. Every man and his dog has opened an Academy hoping to teach cricket-skills to wide-eyed kids. One could concede that these Academies are producing a truck load of bright young kids that do exceedingly well at the Under-19 level. Moreover, where cricket was essentially for the city-dwelling elite and middle-class in India — when it came to big-league opportunities — newer players have come for far-flung places. Dhoni is from Ranchi (in interior Jharkhand), a place without a single player to have ever played for India! The domination of Mumbai, Bangalore, Delhi, Hyderabad, Kolkata and Chennai are no longer present. We have players in the team that used to practice their cricket on railway platforms in Ranchi — indeed, he leads the team today!

The representative level is well-organised and run in India. The Ranji system is strong, although I think that even after splitting the competition into two leagues, the Elite league has 4 teams too many! There is more work to do there, but I do believe that the foundations are better now than they were a 10 years back.

The media in India has always been an issue and a problem. There are sane voices that lead the team towards a better future. But the commercial TV channels and some near-jingoistic broadsheets ruin it for everyone. Unfortunately, there is an audience for sensationalism in India! One hopes that the saner, stronger voices win in the end — and there are plenty of those to give me hope!

As I have said before, in Gary Kirsten, India has the right man. He has no compelling need to be either in the drivers’ seat or indeed, near a microphone! He stays in the background and does his job in much the way that John Wright did. I feel that this man will take Indian cricket forward. Time will tell.

What matters most to me is the right leadership, talent and attitude.

Sourav Ganguly was, in my view, the first real leader of the Indian cricket team. I have been saying that for years. Rahul Dravid would have made a sensational leader of the Australian cricket team! Alas! He was in a place that needed a Ganguly or a Dhoni! He was a cultural misfit! The role needs a leader who was/is able to approach leadership by inspiring inwards and managing outwards! Dravid was a misfit as a leader. Right man, wrong place! Kumble was a “holding pattern” and in Sydney alone he showed qualities that I have not seen in leaders in a long time.

Peter Roebuck has written eloquently about M. S. Dhoni. What he has said does not need repeating.

As a Team India fan dreams again, Dhoni is the right man for the job. Indeed, he is perhaps the one that inspires these dreams!

However, the most important reason for these dreams is the talent and mindset.

The Indian team in Nagpur showed that winning was important for it. Although on day-5 the team did look ragged and confused, the moment they got a wicket or two, neo-normalcy seemed to be restored. Indian teams of old would have caved in. This team regrouped and stuck to its plan again — as it had on day-3 after playing lose cricket at the end of day-2. They had their minds on the job in a focussed manner. In the past, Indian teams could not be accused of either focus or determination, leave alone steely-resolve! This team has all of that in spades and moreover, plays with a hiterto unobserved pride!

There was an almost Australia-like cut-throat edge to its game.

Over the last few years, the timidity and servility that represented Indian teams of the past had given way to aggression, attitude, determination, grit, fight and free-spirit. Agreed! All of the above come to the fore compellingly only when India plays Australia or Pakistan. However, there is a new breed of player that is more and more reflective of the new, brash, bold, adventurous, expressive India! I am not a fan of it, but I realise that that is where the country and its people are at this point in time.

Moreover, with the onset of central contracts and the IPL, I feel that India players play with far greater security. This has always been a concern in Indian cricket. In the past, the India player has had to play with the next game and pay-cheque in mind! But today, a Gautam Gambhir is able to play his natural aggressive game without worrying too much about his next contract or his next pay cheque! He has got it, in spades already.

And I do believe that this last element adds significantly to the make up of the winning mindset. Suddenly, Gautam Gambhir’s existence is no longer an issue. His performance is. He can focus more on giving his best to his country. Even a Joginder Sharma or a Praveen Kumar can come in for a game here or a game there and give off his best. The IPL and central contracts ensure that all that the player needs to focus on is in giving off his best in the game that he is chosen for.

Suddenly there are more players for spots!

Let us look at the list of players that are in contention:

  • Openers: Virender Sehwag, Gautam Gambhir, Murali Vijay, Wasim Jaffer, Akash Chopra [5]
  • Middle-order Batsmen: Rahul Dravid, Sachin Tendulkar, V. V. S. Laxman, Rohit Sharma, S. Badrinath, Suresh Raina, Mohammed Kaif, Yuvraj Singh, Cheteshwar Pujara, Robin Uthappa, Virat Kohli, Ajinkya Rahane, Tanmay Srivastava, Shikar Dhawan [14]
  • Pacemen: Ishant Sharma, Zaheer Khan, Munaf Patel, R. P. Singh, Sree Santh, Irfan Pathan, Praveen Kumar, Pankaj Singh, Manpreet Gony, Ashok Dinda, Siddharth Trivedi, Pradeep Sangwan, Ranadeb Bose [13]
  • Spinners: Harbhajan Singh, Amit Mishra, Piyush Chawla, Pragyan Ojha, Yusuf Pathan, Romesh Powar, Mohnish Parmar [7]
  • Keepers: M. S. Dhoni, Parthiv Patel, Wriddhiman Saha, Dinesh Karthik [4]

That’s a total of 43 players. It is an impressive list of young players. I may have missed out a few and some may question the presence of players like Mohnish Parmar or Shikar Dhawan or Tanmay Srivastava. This is perhaps nothing more than a list of players who are in contention for both the Test as well as the ODI team. Most of the above players have either played for India already (in any of the three forms of the game) or are about to.

India should expand its contract list to include players who regularly turn out for India-A games. India-A should tour continuously and if no one wants to play with India-A, should play against itself! Match readiness should be the name of the game and not the next central contract! A core bunch of about 50 players needs to be identified, nurtured and maintained. They should also be match-ready so that the careers of players like Ishant Sharma, Zaheer Khan, Tendulkar, Dravid, Yuvraj Singh and M. S. Dhoni can be well-managed.

Cheteshwar Pujara has scored three triple centuries in his last four games including one in the recently completed Ranji round! One can’t keep him away from the big league for too long. Gavaskar was pushing for young Pujara even when news of Gautam Gambhir’s Nagpur suspension was filtering through. The selectors went for M. Vijay in that instance.

However, Rahul Dravid will need to now work intensely hard to keep players like Badrinath, Pujara, Rohit Shrama, Yuvraj Singh and Suresh Raina at bay! Kris Srikkanth has said that he has faith in Dravid and feels that a big innings is just around the corner.

I am conservative in this regard — a close friend labeled be “dogged” in this regard. Be that as it may, I am not for a “spill and fill” approach. We have just seen the departure of Kumble and Ganguly from the team. It may be seductive to wipe the slate clean and go for a thrush of youngsters! With important series against England, Pakistan and New Zealand coming up in the next 6 months, if I were selector, I’d give Dravid up until the end of the New Zealand series to make up his mind on the timing of his departure. If he wishes to leave the game before that time, then that would be his call to make. I do believe we need his experience in the team until the New Zealand series at least.

Either way you look at it, it is an impressive collection of players.

After that 281, the Team India fan can dream again!

— Mohan

18 responses to “The Indian fan can dream… again!

  1. chris hutchinson

    @ Mohan

    There was an almost Australia-like cut-throat edge to its game.

    You said it.

    I trust by the way you said you like it?

    Watch the worm turn on the new age cricket that India played.

    Yes! Ponting did get it wrong. His side coudln’t do what he wanted them to do. India could.

  2. @Chris

    I like the way India played on day-3. Indian teams of the past won’t

    But you sure are full of wish-lists for the future! “Watch the worm turn on new age cricket that India played”, “Watch Ponting morph into the Pope”, “Watch Shane Warne become Elvis Presley”! 🙂

  3. chris hutchinson


    I thought i was giving India credit.

    One thing that is obvious is that you guys just keep that self-deprecation button close by.

    One minute it’s India India India jai jai jai.

    The next it’s “let’s keep a lid on this” we don’t want to be too bold we now our station.

    ………and that is not meant to be offensive.

  4. I think I’m starting to see what a “serial pest” is now.

    Mohan, you are a patient man.

  5. I am more or less in agreement with this post. However:
    1. India tends to follow the pattern of not being able to sustain the momentum. They did very well in Australia, followed by a poor series against South Africa and then Sri Lanka, followed by a good series against Aussies again. While the signs are promising, I think it is early days.

    2. I think Rahul Dravid needs to go back to Ranji. Even Rahul can’t get a free ticket.

    3. I thought Rahane & Utthappa are openers. And what have you got against Murali Kartik, Joginder Sharma and L. Balaji?

  6. @RV

    Good points about consistency. I agree with the past as well as your litmus test for the future. India needs to be consistent. That’s how Australia got to where it was/is. I did not suggest that Rahul Dravid gets a free ticket. He does have to go back to the Ranjis. Having said that, I am not in favour of a “spill and fill”. Well Rahane plays 1-down for Mumbai sometimes when Kukreja and Jaffer open. While it is true that Uthappa opens for Karnataka, I can’t see him getting an opening gig for India either for ODIs or Tests.

    Murali Kartik… Not sure…

    Joginder Sharma: Players in the Ranji Plate league do get ignored. I agree. But for some reason he hasn’t been playing for Haryana this year. Does anyone know why?

    L. Balaji: Early days…

  7. chris hutchinson

    Sorry Mohan!

    Am I that bad. Bryan sees me as a serial pest. I like to think my views are balanced.

  8. @Chris

    You can take your wars directly with Bryan. You do not need either an adjudicator or a Match Referee for that one! 🙂

    Back to the India team. How about the following lineup for the 1st ODI and the 1st Test?

    1st ODI:

    Virender Sehwag
    Gautam Gambhir
    Suresh Raina
    Rohit Sharma
    Yuvraj Singh
    MS Dhoni
    Yusuf Pathan
    Harbhajan Singh
    Zaheer Khan
    Munaf Patel
    RP Singh

    Subs: Virat Kohli, Pragyan Ojha, Ishant Sharma, Murali Vijay

    1st Test

    Gautam Gambhir
    Virender Sehwag
    Murali Vijay
    Sachin Tendulkar
    V. V. S. Laxman
    Rahul Dravid
    M. S. Dhoni
    Harbhajan Singh
    Zaheer Khan
    Amit Mishra
    Ishant Sharma

    Subs: S. Badrinath, Cheteshwar Pujara, Munaf Patel, R. P. Singh, Piyush Chawla

    — Mohan

  9. @Chris, your views are as balanced and fair as the Fox News Channel

  10. Tanmay Srivastava is an opener in Ranji. So that takes the tally of openers in the fray to 6.

  11. chris hutchinson

    Thank you raakshas.

    Where is Praveen in the ODI side?

    Rohit Sharma should be in both sides.

  12. Dhawan and Rahane are openers while Robin Uthappa also plays as an opener in Ranji.

    Meanwhile I’m not willing to give up on Tiwari just yet. He is going through a wretched form but I’m sure he’ll do well.

    And Dravid is a big worry these days in tests. He has become a walking wicket now for the opposition. All of us have been waiting for that one big knock which just seems just round the corner since last two years and it hasn’t come till now apart from that scratchy ton against SA on the flattest deck.

  13. Mohan, I’ll be the first to admit that I had my misgivings about Dhoni initially. However, his leadership and inspirational skills have convinced me that he is the best man for the captain’s job. Couple of things he did in the final test (asking Ganguly to captain in the waning hours of the test & asking Kumble to step forward and accept the series trophy jointly at the winner’s podium) were superlative gestures that showed that he has a healthy regard for the past and wished to acknowledge their immense contributions in his own way. Hats off to him for that.

  14. As I said in response to RV, Rahane does play ar #3 for Mumbai sometimes — for example in the last match. Moreover, I do not see him or Uthappa getting an opening gig in ODIs or Tests for sometime now. Hence their inclusion as “batsmen”. I did think hard about Tiwary. And left it there.

  15. @ Mohan,

    Do you think, utilising M Vijay at # 3 would mean that he is future #3 for India?

    Also, somehow I believe that, in the long run (based on the performance) Rohit Sharma can be a #4 for India. Again, that will depend on, who from the players doing the rounds will continue to deliver. Too early to say.

    But, the XI you mentioned for tests looks good to me (especially because it will give an opp to MV to prove himself and give some breather to RD). The only fallout is, if India were to go through a collapse, then RD will be under tremendous pressure as the last line of defense (discounting Dhoni)

  16. @chris
    Your views are more balanced than JB and Steve.There was only one serial pest here and hope that he is gone for good..

  17. I am hoping that India will get this worldcup. Best of Luck India

Leave a Reply to MohanK Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s